- 1952 F.E. Fitzgerald
- 1953 F.E. Fitzgerald
- 1954 Howard Schnell
- 1955 Harry Berg
- 1956 Jim Davis
- 1957 Jim Davis
- 1958 Sylvester Wallace
- 1959 E.L Haibeck
- 1960 K.L. Ferguson
- 1961 Irvin Reiten
- 1962 Bob Penfield
- 1963 Bob Penfield
- 1964 Bob Penfield
- 1965 Stanley Wald
- 1966 Wilbert Kroh
- 1967 Bob Steffes
- 1968 Norm Aldinger
- 1969 Norm Aldinger
- 1970 Charles Wilkes
- 1971 Wilbert Kroh
- 1972 Les Lien
- 1973 Wilbert Kroh
- 1974 Norm Aldinger
- 1975 Tony Heinze
- 1976 Roger Skiftun
- 1977 Arlo Schmidt
- 1978 Wilbert Kroh
- 1979 Bud Rice
- 1980 Sid Stromme
- 1981 Cliff Orr
- 1982 Dick Keil
- 1983 Dennis Bengstron
- 1984 Bob Osendorf
- 1985 Larry Schnell
- 1986 Virgil Tuebner
- 1987 Jean Helgass
- 1988 Milton Brandner
- 1989 Todd Goheen
- 1990 Wayne Trottier
- 1991 Marvin Hoffman
- 1992 Scott Steffes
- 1993 Darrell Graber
- 1994 Gil Steedsman
- 1995 Dennis Biliske
- 1996 Dale Haugen
- 1997 Brad Olstad
- 1998 Lowell Rau
- 1999 Chuck Lang
- 2000 Bob Helbling
- 2001 Lee Halvorson
- 2002 Ron Olson
- 2003 Brian Bosch
- 2004 Troy Orr
- 2005 Gordy Krance
- 2006 Ross Glass
- 2007 Pete Awender
- 2008 Pete Awender
- 2009 Troy Orr
- 2010 Bob Helbling
- 2011 Chuck Lang
- 2012 Gordy Krance
- 2013 Dennis Biliske
- 2014 Clifford Sanders
- 2015 John Kuchera
- 2016 Troy Orr
- 2017 Cliff Sanders
- 2018 Mike Ostrem
- 2019 Cliff Sanders
- 2020 Glenn Trautman II
- 2021 Glenn Trautman II
- 2022 Terry Moe
